Council in PandaCode: reviewers, target scores, 25-round limit
Updated
Illustrative photo
Agents grading their own work
Agents that check their own output tend to approve it. That gap is what pushed the channel behind PandaCode to build a feature called Council. The idea is simple: separate reviewers get to challenge the self-assessment of the agents that did the work. The lowest score counts, not the average, so one weak review can block a finish.
Council exposes three knobs: a target score, a round limit, and the number of reviewers. Each reviewer gets a lens, meaning a specific angle to judge from. Every round brings fresh reviewers who never see the target or the earlier scores, while the lenses stay locked after round one. If the result lands below target, PandaCode refuses the finish and tells the lead agent to fix the blockers and call another round.
What the skill manager run showed
The walkthrough follows a skill manager through its review rounds. It ended at the limit of 25 rounds with a 9 against a 9.5 target, leaving the final call to the person running it. Most rounds moved the score very little.
Getting useful UI reviews
For UIreviews, the advice is to name concrete goals and states, ask for screenshot reviews, and keep appearance separate from interaction behavior. The same applies to the security, release and factual accuracy reviews covered in the walkthrough: each lens needs something specific to check.
The cost: plan usage and mixed models
Council uses more of your plan, because every round spins up reviewers. With Panda Router on, it tries to give each reviewer a different model, which is the mixed-model advice the channel gives. The trade-off is real: more rounds mean more usage, and the skill manager example shows diminishing returns.
A score is not taste
The channel's own verdict is that Council is pretty cool, but a score is not taste and you still decide when to stop. I have not run Council myself, so treat the 9-versus-9.5 example as the channel's account, not a measured result.
Affiliate links: we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases, and it never changes our data or rankings. They open Amazon's search results: prices and availability are shown there.