Skip to content
Sir CompareComparisons with evidenceYouTubeTelegram
United Kingdom · GBP

News

MEV brothers acquitted: judge finds no fraud in $25M Ethereum exploit

Updated

Illustrative photo: Hardware Wallet Crypto: Pexels-david-mcbee-730564
Illustrative photo

The verdict on the $25M exploit

Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud and money laundering charges. The brothers ran an Ethereum validator and exploited MEV bots for around $25 million in April 2023. According to Protos · Crypto investigations (London), the ruling came on Monday after a weeks-long trial last November ended with a deadlocked jury and was deemed a mistrial. Clarke wrote that the government failed to prove the brothers made any material misrepresentations while carrying out the scheme. That point matters because a material misrepresentation is central to a wire fraud conviction.

How the bait-and-switch worked

The pair made roughly $25 million in just 12 seconds, according to the account of the case. They used a bait-and-switch exploit against MEV trading bots and targeted a design flaw in Flashbots' MEV-boost relay. Soon after, the brothers disclosed a different exploit under the name “Low Carb Crusader.” In May 2024 they were indicted on federal charges that prosecutors called a first-of-its kind wire fraud and money laundering scheme. The full list covered wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, conspiracy to commit money laundering, and conspiracy to receive stolen property.

Why the judge sided with the brothers

Clarke described Ethereum as a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use and without the safeguards found in regulated markets. She accepted that the scheme may have frustrated the spirit of MEV-Boost's design, but found no misrepresentation in its execution that could support fraud. She compared the case to Avraham Eisenberg's 2022 exploit of Mango Markets, where charges were overturned on similar reasoning last year. Her opinion is limited to whether the trial evidence was enough for a conviction. It does not address whether the behaviour was right or moral, or whether it broke uncharged crimes.

What the ruling leaves open for validators

Crypto lawyers welcomed the decision for rejecting the prosecution's “honest validator” theory. Coin Center's Peter Van Valkenburgh had worried that theory would let the government impose its own code of conduct on Ethereum validators. Anton Peraire-Bueno, known as “Curious Rabbit” on X, thanked family and friends who rearranged their lives around the case since the indictment. He added that in the end it is a good story when the good guys win. James shared his brother's sentiments and is reportedly looking forward to a celebratory beer.

Related coverage

Source: Protos · Crypto investigations (London)

Video

What changed

  • Page updated

How I put products in order

Sir Compare’s letter

Updates on Crypto hardware wallets? I’ll send them your way.

Pick what you care about: I only write when something new comes out — a guide, a news story, a verified price that drops.

Step 1 of 2

What are you into?

Pick as many as you like. Pick none and you get what’s new in every section.

What you want to receive
  • Only what you pick
  • Never an empty email
  • One click to leave

Your assistant

Open full page →